Women’s hormones have been misunderstood, dismissed and overlooked for far too long.
And frankly, we’ve had enough.
Welcome to The Third Opinion, a new Substack from Dr Louise Newson, Dr Val Pollard and Jill Chmielewski RN. We are three healthcare professionals, with three different perspectives and one shared determination: to challenge the status quo and demand better for women’s hormone health.
We’re also friends.
Louise and Val first met at medical school 32 years ago, forging a friendship through the decades as students, junior doctors together in New Zealand and both working in frontline UK healthcare. Jill and Louise have known each other for several years, initially building a friendship across the Atlantic through their work on hormones before working more closely together through Jill’s involvement with the Balance hormones and menopause app, which was founded by Louise.
Between us, we’ve spent countless hours poring over the latest hormone research, sharing experiences from our clinical practice and discussing the stories of women whose symptoms have been dismissed, misunderstood or ignored.
We challenge each other, but we share one fundamental belief: that women deserve better – better information, better choices and better healthcare.
And we’re not afraid to say so.
Why The Third Opinion?
Because sometimes the established medical opinion needs challenging.
We’re tired of hearing about women being told their symptoms are something they have to put up with, that they’re too young, too old, or that it’s all in their heads.
We’re fed up and frustrated with stories from women whose clinicians are refusing to prescribe them bioidentical hormone treatments (progesterone, estradiol and testosterone) which will both improve symptoms and future health of these women.
And because medical misogyny, hormone misinformation and gaps in medical education continue to detrimentally affect women’s lives.
About us
We each bring something different to the conversation.
Louise is a leading physician and women’s hormone expert, founder of Newson Clinic and the Balance app, Sunday Times bestselling author, host of the UK’s number one medical podcast and dubbed ‘the medic who kickstarted the menopause revolution’. She’s devoted the last decade to challenging conventional thinking about menopause, hormone treatments (HRT) and hormone health, campaigning for better education and improved access to hormone treatments.
Val recently left an established NHS career to join the team at Newson Clinic, spurred on by her desire to join a forward-thinking group of clinicians committed to improving women’s hormone health. With decades of clinical and academic experience, she brings invaluable frontline insight into the realities of women’s healthcare, the challenges clinicians face and the barriers women encounter when seeking hormone treatment.
Jill brings more than 30 years of nursing experience, a US healthcare perspective and a fierce commitment to informed consent, women’s autonomy and putting women in control of their health. She advocates for women whose symptoms and concerns are too often left out of the conversation. A central focus of her work is challenging blanket hormone bans after breast cancer and advancing more transparent conversations about evidence, uncertainty and informed choice.
We have different backgrounds, and different experiences. But we have a shared refusal to accept that the current standard of hormone treatment is good enough.
What can you expect from The Third Opinion?
You can expect honest opinions, no-holds-barred views and conversations that aren’t afraid to get uncomfortable.
Through regular essays we’ll scrutinise the latest hormone research, challenge long-held medical assumptions, call out misinformation and explore why progress in women’s hormone healthcare can be so agonisingly slow.
We’ll be tackling medical misogyny, gaps in medical education, the barriers to accessing hormone treatments and the issues that deserve more attention.
And The Third Opinion isn’t just about perimenopause and menopause.
Hormone imbalances affect women throughout their lives. From periods, PMS, PMDD, PMOS, and endometriosis through to contraception, pregnancy, postnatal mental health, perimenopause, menopause and healthy ageing, we’ll explore the bigger picture and ask the questions that too often go unanswered.
You can expect personal reflections, provocative opinions and evidence-based insights. We’ll share what excites us about new research, what concerns us about current practice and what we believe needs to change.
We won’t pretend every question has a simple answer, but we won’t by shying away from asking the difficult questions.
A new kind of hormone health discussion
You may already know us through The Dr Louise Newson Podcast, the Dr Louise Newson website or the Balance app.
Empowering women with evidence-based information is at the heart of what we do, and The Third Opinion builds on that work – but this is where we get personal.
We’ll share what frustrates us, what inspires us, what keeps us awake at night and what we believe needs to change.
Think of The Third Opinion as a place for the conversations that don’t always fit neatly into an educational article or a clinical guideline.
The Third Opinion is a place to question, challenge, debate and occasionally ruffle a few feathers.
Because progress rarely comes from accepting that things have always been done a certain way.
Join our conversation
We’re here because we believe all women deserve to be heard, informed and taken seriously. All women should have a choice about taking hormone treatments.
And we believe that meaningful change requires more than one-off awareness days or fluffy campaigns. Real change happens when people are willing to challenge entrenched attitudes and keep pushing for better.
We have lots to say. And we suspect you do, too.
So subscribe today to The Third Opinion for honest, evidence-based perspectives on women’s hormones, healthcare and the issues that deserve more attention.
Dr Louise Newson, Dr Val Pollard and Jill Chmielewski RN
The content published on The Third Opinion is intended for general information and educational purposes only. It is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment.
Always seek advice from your doctor or another qualified healthcare professional if you have questions about a medical condition or treatment. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay seeking it because of something you have read in this publication. If you think you may be experiencing a medical emergency, contact the emergency services in your country or seek immediate medical assistance.






I’d love to hear more about testosterone as part of an HRT regime; and what to do about those stupid foil packets!
So pleased you’re here on Substack Dr Newson! You’ve taught me more than almost anyone over the years and I’m looking forward to reading everything 🤍